FCTO In
the News
Communities Feel Effects of Taxpayer
Groups
Budgets Rejected in
Referendums
May 24, 2004 Waterbury Republican News Article by Chuck Petruccione
After he
forced Thomaston's municipal budget to a referendum, Tony Durso
did not celebrate. It's not a victory, he said, it's the beginning of a war. "This can't be a one-shot deal where we
just look at one budget," Durso said. So he has
begun collecting names in the hopes of creating a permanent taxpayer watchdog
organization in town. His idea may be
new to Thomaston, but it is part of a growing trend across the region and
around the state. In Torrington, Naugatuck and New Hartford, taxpayer
watchdog groups have formed within the last year. The groups join others
including Watertown, Winsted and New Britain, which is Connecticut's oldest at 75
years. The
Federation of Connecticut Taxpayer
Organizations, formed in the mid-1980s to promote fiscal accountability by the
state and in cities and towns, lists 28 different town organizations on its Web
site. Susan Kniep,
president of the coalition, said taxpayer worries have been bubbling just below
the surface for years, and tough economic times are bringing to the fore. In Torrington, an
organization was launched over the superintendent of schools' hefty pay
contract. The Naugatuck group came
about because some residents felt school spending was driving the town's tax
rate out of control. Kniep
said other groups have formed because of corruption scandals in cities like Waterbury and Bridgeport. At the state
level, investigators are examining records to determine whether Gov. John G.
Rowland's gifts from friends were in exchange for lucrative contracts. Kniep said taxpayer
distrust of politicians is leading them to question budget appropriations. That
prompted Thomaston's Durso to demand a referendum and
set the stage for the formation of his town's watchdog group. Durso said if
Thomaston's proposed 2004-05 budget passes, the average homeowner will see
taxes bounce from $3,469 this year to $4,097 next year, an 18 percent jump. Rob Kane, chairman of the Town Council in
Watertown, where the Watertown-Oakville Taxpayer's Association has been active
for nearly 15 years, said it makes sense that residents in many towns are
coming together fight tax increases. "The
price of everything is going up including milk and gas," Kane said.
"Everything affects your pocket book, so nobody wants to pay more in
taxes. The only place that taxpayers truly have any kind of say in their
government is at the local level." Kniep said taxpayer group membership is growing and they're flexing their
muscles by exercising their constitutional rights to petition. "That is the only protection we have, to
be able to defeat a budget and send it back to the officials," Kniep said. "We have to tell them what we are willing
to pay in taxes, not what they will impose on us. You are seeing budget
referendums being defeated all over the state." Since the
beginning of the month, voters have rejected the following budgets:
Seymour's combined town
and school budget
The Region 6
school budget, which includes Warren, Morris and Goshen
The Region 7
school budget, which includes New Hartford, Colebrook, Norfolk and Barkhamsted
The Region 14
school budget, which includes Woodbury and Bethlehem
The Region 15
school budget, which includes Middlebury and Southbury
The Region 16
school budget, which includes Prospect and Beacon Falls
Litchfield's combined school and town budget
Watertown's combined
school and town budget
In Region
7, New Hartford's Citizens for
Responsible Government sent a flier to residents outlining concerns about the
proposed 5.86 percent budget increase. Voters then rejected the budget 648-267,
although it passed in each of the district's three other towns. Mark Hawley,
president of the group, said it's not a coincidence. There is a watchdog group
in his town but not in the district's other towns, Barkhamsted,
Colebrook and Hartland. "We can
make a difference, there's no doubt about it," Hawley said. Using a flier is similar to efforts that have
proven effective time and again in Watertown. Jack Walton, spokesman for Watertown's group,
said it also is not uncommon for his group to put up lawn signs or take out
advertisements in newspapers when they don't support a proposed budget. He said
the group's expenses are covered by the annual $10 dues paid by each of the
group's 500 members. While taxpayer
groups rally to defeat budgets they say are irresponsible, those in charge of
crafting budgets say residents simply don't understand that increases often are
necessary. In Plymouth, a recent town
meeting had to beat back motions aimed at cutting between $800,000 and $1.6
million from the budget. David Merchant, chairman of the town's board of
finance, said it is disturbing to see the work of his committee nearly
decimated by a motion that doesn't include suggestions for where to cut. Clifford Brammer,
first selectman in Thomaston, said he doesn't think a referendum on the budget
is a good idea for exactly that reason. He said only allowing residents to say
yes or no to the bottom line is a bad idea. "There is not a line item to cut from on
the town side. We will be cutting services or employees," Brammer said. "If people are willing to cut services,
come forward and tell us where to cut." Steven Angelo has been the town manager in
Winsted since December. He said he has seen taxpayer organizations in other
places he has worked, including Massachusetts, where people
just call for cuts all the time without being reasonable. He said that doesn't
benefit anyone. Skip Page, president of
the Torrington Citizen Action Coalition, which was just formed this year, said
his group intends to watch what the Board of Finance, Board of Education and
mayor do, but they are not in place only to oppose those entities. "We will take on any issues that we feel
are important, even if that means supporting the town," Page said. As an example, Page said the coalition and the
city are in agreement that binding arbitration for salary disputes is a
disservice to towns and taxpayers. "I
think it's always helpful to have additional citizens look at what we do,"
Angelo said. Kane agrees. He said he may
not always be on the same page as the taxpayer's association, but he values
their input. "I'm glad they get
involved," Kane said. "It's easy for people to sit on the sidelines,
but at least they come to the budget meetings. Whether they agree with me or
not, this is still a democratic process, and I welcome participation from
everyone."